patching...
Breaking: Plainfield Park District Special Meeting Canceled »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Plainfield Barnes & Noble Store to Close

Bookstore will close by end of year, company says; the Plainfield Staples store has also called it quits.

 

A dispute over the cost of rent is the apparent cause of the demise of Plainfield’s Barnes & Noble store.

A rep for the company this week confirmed that the store will close by the end of the year after the bookseller was unable to work out a new lease agreement with its landlord.

Shoppers at the location, open for more than a decade, were greeted this week by large signs advertising a storewide clearance sale.

Get Plainfield news in your inbox — sign up for the Plainfield Patch newsletter.

Without elaborating, Barnes & Noble Vice President of Development David Deason issued a statement on the store closing.

“We worked diligently with the property owner to work out an agreement that would allow us to keep the store open; unfortunately we were unable to reach an economic agreement,” Deason said.

The store is located in the Kensington Center development, which is anchored by a Target store and home to retailers including Maurice’s, Dress Barn and GameStop.

Edwards Realty Company, which manages the property, did not respond to Patch’s request for comment.

Village Planner Michael Garrigan said the village worked to help the two parties come to an agreement.

“The village attempted to be very, very aggressive as it relates to making sure they did not vacate or leave that store,” Garrigan said. “Obviously, there’s no other way to say it — it’s a setback. Barnes & Noble is an important tenant.”

Garrigan said the village was willing to offer a “substantial” sales tax rebate to help keep the store open.

However, Garrigan said neither side seemed all that invested in reaching an agreement.

“Unfortunately, [Barnes & Noble] didn’t perceive the numbers came out in their favor,” he said. “It’s my understanding that they were an underperforming store.”

Meanwhile, the landlord may have some other prospects for renting the space, Garrigan said.

“It was a business decision,” he said. “The landlord was willing to do everything possible … They couldn’t give the space away.”

While Garrigan said he would like to see another bookstore set up shop in the location, he acknowledged that brick and mortar booksellers are struggling, especially as readers embrace downloadable e-books.

“Unfortunately, it’s a national trend,” he said.

The closing isn’t the only recent retail casualty in Plainfield; the Staples store, 13305 S. Route 59, has closed, Garrigan said.

Staples did not respond to messages from Patch.

----------------

Follow Plainfield Patch on Facebook.

Related Topics: Barnes & Noble, Barnes & Noble Closing, Business Closing, Staples, and Store Closing

T-Bone

6:46 am on Thursday, November 29, 2012

Maybe we can get a Big Lots store in Plainfield now to fill this Huge hole! But then what do we do in the Staples empty building...hmmm

Landlords are either stupid around here or just catch all the blame because they will not comment and defend themselves...

Reply

RB

7:11 am on Thursday, November 29, 2012

I'm not sure the landlord is the problem in this case. Barnes & Noble stores have no future. Most of the other booksellers already went under and they are next in line. I like books and newspapers but both business are doomed.

Reply

Michael G. D'Aversa

7:21 am on Thursday, November 29, 2012

It's hard to feel sorry for landlords, but we can probably guess their defense. If you think about it, they purchased and developed these properties back when prices were sky high and still rising. I imagine they would like to charge rents that will enable them to cover that initial cost, pay down their debt obligations, etc. Lease rates, however, seek their own level, just like property values. Maybe the only difference between low rent and no rent is how fast the landlord goes bust. All I know is now everybody loses. B&N loses a location, the developer has a big empty unit, and we lose our B&N. Too late now...

Reply

Mom of Four

7:48 am on Thursday, November 29, 2012

I heard that Trader Joes is going in there! That would be Awesome!!!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Grandpamike

11:24 am on Thursday, November 29, 2012

I hope that is true, that would be a great asset for Plainfield.

MidwestGal

8:02 am on Thursday, November 29, 2012

This stinks - this site is going to become ANOTHER empty store in Plainfiled. TJs would be great, but I doubt it's true....they've been talking about a Vandyke and 126 location for years. Hopefully NOT a Big Lots or Ultra Foods, please nothing trashy - we already have Walmart acreoss the way for that. B & N president just said last week HE doesn't even read paper books - he uses tablets and ereaders - so I guess it was a matter of time.

Reply

Nicole

8:42 am on Thursday, November 29, 2012

I agree with MidwestGal, Big Lots would be a big mess! Very low-class dirty store. This about every area there is a Big Lots. Lots of closed stores, surrounded by unpopular, low-end sales stores and unkepmt areas. I am sad to see B&N go. I love that store. I have not taken to e-books for my kids, so we would always go there for books for my boys.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Verbal Sniper

8:27 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012

Sounds like your basing your opinion on the Crest Hill location.The Bolingbrook and Naperville locations are clean and organized.I shop there,does that make me low class?

Linda L.

9:18 am on Thursday, November 29, 2012

I had heard they wanted Barnes and Noble to sign a 10 year lease! Book sales could be extinct in ten years. Wish the landlords had been more realistic. Too bad for all of us who sHopped there.

Reply

EdCenter

9:59 am on Thursday, November 29, 2012

I think another frozen yogurt shop would be a great addition.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Sheila Raddatz

10:16 am on Thursday, November 29, 2012

Yeah, we only have two or three of them (yogurt shops) within a walking distance from BN. haha

Grandpamike

11:28 am on Thursday, November 29, 2012

If it up to the Plainfield board to approve business license's, I would hope that they would not just jump in a allow any store to open in that space. They should think about the long term and consider a business that will enhance Plainfield and not make it another type that would just make Plainfield residents shop elsewhere.

Reply

AZyburt

1:12 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012

I'd love to see a Home Goods!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Sheila Raddatz

2:22 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012

My wishlist: BestBuy, JCPenny, Bed, Bath & Beyond, Michaels, Trader Joes, or a movie theater.

Linda

2:35 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012

A Home Goods or Trader joes would be awesome. We don't need another yogurt place or tire & lube place. And please don't put something Trashy there.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Tom A

10:10 am on Saturday, December 1, 2012

That would be one big yogurt store!

Droncz87

3:45 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012

Trader Joes would kinda draw attention away from that neat little Store in town along 59 by Plainfield Central.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Sheila Raddatz

3:49 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012

I agree and disagree, people on the North side of town have sort of been "trained" to avoid anything south of 143rd on Rt 59 by the YEARS of construction.

Ron

4:32 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012

Forget the wish list of stores. How about new members on the Village Board that actually want to bring in commercial/industrial business into the Village?

Reply

T-Bone

6:34 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012

Maybe we will get a Salvation Army Thrift Shop now!!

Reply

Kevin S

7:06 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012

Sad to see it go because I always enjoy shopping there and we have no other booksellers left around here, but I have a sense that B&N is looking to get out of the brick & mortar game entirely. Perhaps wise from a business standpoint, sad for people who still love bookstores. As for TJ's, that would be awesome but I sent them an email about six months ago asking why they don't open in the 59 corridor because so many people here want them. They responded that they appreciate all of us, but had no plans to expand in our area in the next two years. They are already operating their other brand (Aldi) at 135th, but that's no TJ's. I hope they have changed their minds!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Jim W

9:47 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012

I e-mail Trader Joe's once or twice a year as well, telling them our demographics and all of the available storefronts that could be had for a song. Their responses are always polite, but never very encouraging. The Naperville TJ's used to ask for your zipcode everytime you went in there, but they stopped doing that a year ago. :-(

GJ

11:32 pm on Thursday, November 29, 2012

How about a Below $5 store
Boooooo! Moo-hahahah scarey!

Reply

Voice of Reason

7:19 am on Friday, November 30, 2012

What a great spot for a sporting goods store, since there isn't one in Plainfield.

Reply
Comment_arrow

CoachB

1:27 pm on Thursday, December 6, 2012

Have you ever heard of Eich's?

Lori Janiec

7:24 am on Saturday, December 1, 2012

So VERY sad to see this store go. It's been an anchor in our shopping life as my husband, daughter and I are all avid readers. The staff is always friendly and helpful there and aside from the library, love perusing the books and magazines. Very sad news. We have lost some valuable businesses lately and it is scary. Meanwhile, we have strip malls that have been vacant for YEARS due to unreasonable lease demands. Why isn't something being done about that?

Reply

Buckgrove

7:42 am on Saturday, December 1, 2012

I wll miss the B and N bookstore in Plainfield. Now we have to travel to the bookstores we used to visit before this one was built. Perhaps a local bookstore in downtown Plainfield?

Reply

Jimmy

9:46 am on Saturday, December 1, 2012

Sorry to see this store go. Hopefully the landlord can work with a new tenant.

Reply

Tom Nosal

9:01 am on Monday, December 3, 2012

OfficeMax, Staples, Limestone Brewery and now Barnes and Noble. Plainfield can't seem to keep and support businesses.

Wonder how long it will be before the 4 lube businesses the village allowed to open at 135th St. and Rte 59 will start going under?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Grandpamike

10:17 am on Monday, December 3, 2012

@Tom

What can the village do to stop business from closing once hey are open ? Opening a new business is a risk, the risk being that they won't generate enough business to stay afloat. Happens all the time. Old business closes, new one opens up, has been that way forever. Should the village pass a bond issue to subsidize business in Plainfield ? This is just another case of a strip mall owner not being able to finance his own debt and passes it on to the tenants who can't afford higher rents so, voila, the business leaves.

ginakoch

9:28 pm on Wednesday, December 26, 2012

My boyfriend and I I mad that ba
No that we love to read

Reply

ginakoch

9:33 pm on Wednesday, December 26, 2012

Why the book stoe in Plainfield that my favorite places got and s my.boyfriend
We love to read their we got know the worker that sad

Reply

ginakoch

9:34 pm on Wednesday, December 26, 2012

My comments reject make be mad

Reply

CB

11:58 pm on Saturday, December 29, 2012

There is nothing like a bookstore. It has a feel good atmosphere and the smell of a bookstore is very comforting. Such a good place for some peace and quiet with a good cuppa joe! All the good things of life slowly going away...sad. Got a kindle for christmas but it takes getting used to...still like the feel of that book in my hand with a fancy bookmark!

Reply

DN Cyentific

1:51 am on Sunday, December 30, 2012

I think a large do it yourself yogurt palace with a big lots inside where the Starbucks is.

Reply

Tiffany S.

12:37 pm on Saturday, January 5, 2013

Hey! I personally like Walmart! Anywho, I was presented with a Kindle Fire and an iPad for Christmas, but none of it compares to a cuddling up with a good tangible book! It's unfortunate that we have to lose another great store.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Plainfield Reader

2:01 pm on Saturday, January 5, 2013

I agree. I love my e-reader but still love a good physical book. Lucky you getting a Kindle Fire and an Ipad both for Christmas. Sure beats the kitchen strainer I got, LOL!

Plainfield Reader

1:57 pm on Saturday, January 5, 2013

I am very sorry to see the Barnes and Noble close. I have a Nook but still love to go to the book store and browse through books especially within 5 minutes of my house. Also bummed that we lost both Office Max and Staples. I do wonder how long that former Barnes and Noble location will stay empty. Too bad the landlord was unwilling to give a shorter lease than 10 years to Barnes and Noble.

Reply

Cj

7:23 pm on Sunday, February 10, 2013

I'm so sad this placed closed down. It was one of the places were I can get some studying. Actually, why not open a used bookstore? Like a Frugal Muse in Darien, but with a little cafe.

Reply

Leave a comment